“Train Dreams” is a film that, in theory, should be one a viewer can fully embrace. In practice, though, it’s another story.
Speaking of story, the one at play here revolves around Robert (Joel Edgerton). A laborer in Idaho, Robert finds himself getting work in the timber and railroad industries starting in the 1910s. It’s around this time he also meets Gladys (Felicity Jones), who he begins a relationship with and later marries.
The film follows his time at home, as he builds a life with Gladys and the two have a child. The audience also gets to see his days at work, where he meets others from across the country who’ve come to the forested terrain to earn a living.
There is a definite beauty to “Train Dreams.” That’s not in question. Several moments in the feature play out like cinematic poetry, and these meditative scenes are admirable. The movie, based off a 2011 book of the same name, is a reflective one, following its lead character through ups and downs in life with quiet observation.
Despite its wide-ranging beauty, though, its ability to resonate with the viewer is small. The movie can feel far too detached, with a lot of dialogue and narration that can come across as overly pie-in-the-sky and lofty. That’s not to say it’s void of quality or meaning, but for a film about one’s life, it can feel lacking in humanity.
It’s a shame because it’s an inviting film that’s quite visually striking. There are several wonderful shots and the way the movie shows the nature around the characters as it transforms with industry is sublime. Yet there are so many times what’s on screen, despite looking good, lacks richness.
Director Clint Bentley, who penned 2024’s “Sing Sing,” co-wrote “Train Dreams” with Greg Kwedar. He does show a strong level of craftsmanship with the movie. However, the presentation of its characters leaves a lot to be desired.
Simple scenes of Robert enjoying time back home with his family, or moments later in the picture where he’s processing how to move forward after hardship, offer a grounded insight into the ups and downs of rugged American life. However, it feels like there’s always a bit of separation between the lives of the characters and the audience.
There’s a lack of personality in the characters and the narrative, and combined with an overbearing narration, the movie doesn’t feel lived in. It’s unfortunate because the acting talent is there.
Joel Edgerton and Felicity Jones are both talented performers and that does shine through in some key scenes. William H. Macy is also a good in a limited, but important role, portraying one of Robert’s co-workers. One just wishes the characters had a bit more, well, character.
“Train Dreams” is a film with quality, that’s for sure. There’s talent in front of and behind the camera, and it shows. Its themes dealing with the human experience in the midst of a changing world, shown through strong cinematography is commendable. But when push comes to shove, this one is hollow, leaving a viewer cold. 2.75 out of 5.
Matthew Liedke on Film 